Judge Fined $5,000 for Shielding Immigrant from ICE in Court
A former Wisconsin judge was convicted of a felony for helping a Mexican immigrant avoid ICE agents inside her own courtroom — and then received only a $5,000 fine instead of prison time. The case is the first of its kind in Wisconsin and sent a clear message: ICE can arrest immigrants at courthouse hearings, even when a judge tries to stop it. If you have an upcoming court date, this ruling directly affects your safety.
What happened in the Dugan case
A former Wisconsin judge avoided prison after being convicted of felony obstruction for helping a Mexican immigrant slip away from ICE agents inside her courthouse. On July 8, 2026, a federal judge fined Hannah Dugan, 67, just $5,000 — far below the 15 to 21 months in prison that federal sentencing guidelines called for. The sentencing judge said the incident was "a marked deviation from an otherwise law-abiding life" and that prison was not necessary.
The events that led to the conviction happened on April 18, 2025. ICE officers came to the Milwaukee county courthouse to arrest Eduardo Flores-Ruiz, 31, a Mexican national who had re-entered the US illegally and was scheduled to appear before Dugan in a state battery case. Dugan confronted the agents, told them their administrative warrant was not enough to arrest Flores-Ruiz inside the courthouse, and directed them to the chief judge's office. After the agents left, she led Flores-Ruiz and his attorney out through a private jury door. Agents spotted him in a corridor, chased him outside, and arrested him. Flores-Ruiz was deported in November 2025.
Immigration Deadlines 2026 — Free
Download PDF with all key dates
Dugan's defense team argued that the Trump administration used her prosecution to pressure judges into cooperating with ICE's strategy of arresting immigrants at court hearings. Dugan herself said her actions were meant to protect the "decorum and safety of the courtroom," not to break the law. While jurors convicted her of felony obstruction, they acquitted her of a separate misdemeanor charge of concealing an individual to prevent arrest. Dugan had already resigned her nine-year judgeship in January amid Republican threats of impeachment. Her attorneys say they plan to appeal the conviction.
Why this matters if you have a court date
This case is the first time a Wisconsin state judge went to trial for obstructing immigration agents. It confirms that ICE can and does send agents to state courthouses to arrest immigrants who appear for scheduled hearings — even in routine criminal or civil cases. The arrest of Flores-Ruiz happened despite a judge's attempt to intervene, and the sentencing judge noted that Dugan's actions did not ultimately stop ICE from making the arrest.
What to do
- If you have a court date and are worried about your immigration status, talk to an immigration lawyer before you go. A lawyer can review your case and explain your risks.
- Do not skip your court hearing without legal advice — missing a hearing can lead to a removal order (deportation order) being issued against you automatically.
- Know that an administrative warrant (also called a civil immigration warrant) is different from a criminal warrant signed by a judge. Lawyers say you have the right to ask what type of warrant ICE is using.
- If ICE approaches you, you have the right to remain silent and the right to speak with an attorney. Do not sign any documents without legal counsel.
Fishkin Law Firm, New York
This case confirms that ICE courthouse arrests are legally permitted and will continue even when a judge objects — the conviction stands and the appeal does not pause enforcement. If you have a pending court date, you should know that an administrative (civil) immigration warrant does not require a judge's signature and gives ICE authority to arrest you outside a courtroom. Consult an immigration attorney before your hearing to discuss whether any protective options — such as a stay of removal or a pending application — apply to your situation.