Immigrant·News

US Immigration · Legal Guides · Attorney Q&A

Policy

US Citizen Shot by CBP Agent Sues Federal Government

Marimar Martinez was shot seven times by a CBP agent during a 2025 Chicago immigration raid — then arrested at the hospital while still bleeding through her bandages. Federal prosecutors dropped the charges against her within a month. Now, one year after the shooting, she is suing the US government, and her lawyers say the agent's own account to the FBI was a lie.

Yesterday·3 min read
US Citizen Shot by CBP Agent Sues Federal Government

You are driving in your own neighborhood when federal agents surround your car — and one of them opens fire. That is what Marimar Martinez, a US citizen, says happened to her on October 4, 2025, during a large-scale immigration enforcement operation in Chicago called Operation Midway Blitz. One year later, on October 6, 2026, she filed a federal lawsuit against the US government, alleging that CBP agent Charles Exum lied to the FBI about what happened and shot her from behind.

What the lawsuit claims

Martinez's attorneys commissioned an expert to analyze bullet trajectories and her injuries. Their findings directly contradict what Exum told the FBI on the day of the shooting. Attorney Chris Parente said Exum told investigators that Martinez drove her car directly at him, that he fired five shots through the windshield, and that he stopped shooting once he was no longer in the vehicle's path. Parente called those statements "three objective lies." The expert analysis found only three bullet holes in the windshield — on the right passenger side, not the driver's side — and a fifth bullet hole in the back of Martinez's car seat, indicating the final shot came from behind her. Parente said Exum had walked several feet toward her car and fired all five shots in less than one second, with the last shot fired through the rear passenger window while Martinez was crouched over the steering wheel. Martinez survived with seven gunshot wounds.

Immigration Policy Checklist — Free

DACA, TPS, Executive Orders: what to monitor

Federal prosecutors initially charged Martinez with using her vehicle to strike Exum's SUV. They dropped those charges within a month of the shooting — a significant reversal in a case that drew national attention. Body-worn camera footage from another agent in Exum's vehicle captured the agents saying it was "time to get aggressive" before the shooting, according to the lawsuit. The FBI arrested Martinez at the hospital just hours after she was shot, while she was still in a wheelchair with bandages leaking blood, the lawsuit states. A judge ordered her release two days later.

The lawsuit was filed under the Federal Tort Claims Act (a law that allows people to sue the US government for harm caused by federal employees). Because of how that law works, Exum himself is not named as a defendant. CBP told the Associated Press that Exum has been placed on administrative leave and that use-of-force cases are reviewed by an independent board. Martinez is not the only person shot in a car by a federal agent during recent immigration enforcement operations. A Venezuelan delivery driver was shot and wounded in Austin, Texas, in September 2026, and a Colombian driver was fatally shot in Biddeford, Maine, in July 2026. At a news conference on October 6, Martinez said she filed suit partly because of those other cases. "What's happening is not normal. We shouldn't stay here and normalize what's happening," she said.

What to do if you witness or experience a use-of-force incident by federal agents

  • Write down everything you remember immediately — the time, location, what agents said, and what happened — before details fade.
  • If you or someone you know was injured by a federal agent, contact an immigration lawyer and a civil rights attorney as soon as possible. The Federal Tort Claims Act has strict deadlines for filing claims against the government.
  • If you are stopped by federal agents during an immigration operation, you have the right to remain silent. You do not have to answer questions about your immigration status without a lawyer present.
  • Document any injuries with photos and keep all medical records — this evidence is critical if you later file a complaint or lawsuit.
Attorney's Advice on This Topic
Илья Фишкин — иммиграционный адвокат
Ilya Fishkin

Immigration attorney, 20+ years of experience

Fishkin Law Firm, New York

Cases like this show why documenting everything after a federal enforcement encounter matters so much. Under the Federal Tort Claims Act, you must first file an administrative claim with the agency — in this case CBP — before you can bring a lawsuit, and you generally have two years from the date of the incident to do so. If you believe a federal agent used unlawful force against you, do not give any statements to investigators without an attorney present, because those statements can be used against you later. Consult a civil rights or immigration attorney as soon as possible to protect your rights and preserve your legal options.

More about the expert →

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a US citizen be arrested by immigration agents during an immigration raid?

Yes, it can happen — and it did in this case. Federal agents arrested Marimar Martinez, a US citizen, during Operation Midway Blitz. If you are a US citizen and are detained by immigration agents, clearly state that you are a citizen and ask for a lawyer immediately. You have the right not to answer questions without legal representation.

What is the Federal Tort Claims Act, and how does it let someone sue the government?

The Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA) is a law that allows people to sue the US government when a federal employee causes them harm while doing their job. Before filing a lawsuit in court, you must first submit a formal administrative claim to the agency involved. There are strict deadlines — generally two years from the date of the incident. An attorney can help you meet those deadlines.

Does an immigrant have the right to remain silent during an ICE or CBP stop?

Yes. Everyone in the US — regardless of immigration status — has the right to remain silent under the Fifth Amendment. You do not have to answer questions about where you were born or your immigration status. Lawyers recommend saying clearly: 'I am exercising my right to remain silent. I want to speak to a lawyer.' Do not run, and do not physically resist.

What should I do if I witness a federal agent use force against someone during an immigration operation?

Write down everything you saw — time, location, what was said, and what happened — as soon as it is safe to do so. If you can, note the agent's badge number or vehicle number. Share what you witnessed with the injured person's attorney. Do not interfere physically with agents, as that could put you at legal risk.

Section:Policy
Share:

Immigration Policy Checklist — Free

DACA, TPS, Executive Orders: what to monitor

Related Articles
Page #article-us-citizen-shot-cbp-agent-sues-federal-government